Skip to content
Submit
Close search
3. N Kringle Place Santa Claus, IN 47579
Submit
Search
Log in
Cart
Currency
AED
AFN
ALL
AMD
ANG
AUD
AWG
AZN
BAM
BBD
BDT
BGN
BIF
BND
BOB
BSD
BWP
BZD
CAD
CDF
CHF
CNY
CRC
CVE
CZK
DJF
DKK
DOP
DZD
EGP
ETB
EUR
FJD
FKP
GBP
GMD
GNF
GTQ
GYD
HKD
HNL
HUF
IDR
ILS
INR
ISK
JMD
JPY
KES
KGS
KHR
KMF
KRW
KYD
KZT
LAK
LBP
LKR
MAD
MDL
MKD
MMK
MNT
MOP
MUR
MVR
MWK
MYR
NGN
NIO
NPR
NZD
PEN
PGK
PHP
PKR
PLN
PYG
QAR
RON
RSD
RWF
SAR
SBD
SEK
SGD
SHP
SLL
STD
THB
TJS
TOP
TTD
TWD
TZS
UAH
UGX
USD
UYU
UZS
VND
VUV
WST
XAF
XCD
XOF
XPF
YER
Shop
Shop Menu
Shop
Arts & Crafts
Active & Outdoor
Baby & Toddler
Books
Building Sets
Christmas
Games & Puzzles
Girls & Dolls
Imaginative Play
Learning & Educational
Magic & Pranks
Music
Novelty
Plush & Puppet
Putty & Slime
RC & Vehicle
Science & Nature
Best Sellers
New Arrivals
Hours
Specialty Toys?
Currency
AED
AFN
ALL
AMD
ANG
AUD
AWG
AZN
BAM
BBD
BDT
BGN
BIF
BND
BOB
BSD
BWP
BZD
CAD
CDF
CHF
CNY
CRC
CVE
CZK
DJF
DKK
DOP
DZD
EGP
ETB
EUR
FJD
FKP
GBP
GMD
GNF
GTQ
GYD
HKD
HNL
HUF
IDR
ILS
INR
ISK
JMD
JPY
KES
KGS
KHR
KMF
KRW
KYD
KZT
LAK
LBP
LKR
MAD
MDL
MKD
MMK
MNT
MOP
MUR
MVR
MWK
MYR
NGN
NIO
NPR
NZD
PEN
PGK
PHP
PKR
PLN
PYG
QAR
RON
RSD
RWF
SAR
SBD
SEK
SGD
SHP
SLL
STD
THB
TJS
TOP
TTD
TWD
TZS
UAH
UGX
USD
UYU
UZS
VND
VUV
WST
XAF
XCD
XOF
XPF
YER
Shop
Arts & Crafts
Active & Outdoor
Baby & Toddler
Books
Building Sets
Christmas
Games & Puzzles
Girls & Dolls
Imaginative Play
Learning & Educational
Magic & Pranks
Music
Novelty
Plush & Puppet
Putty & Slime
RC & Vehicle
Science & Nature
Best Sellers
New Arrivals
Hours
Specialty Toys?
Collection:
Plush & Puppet
Filter by
Age
Age 3 Months+
Age 3+
Age 4+
Sort by
Featured
Best Selling
A-Z
Z-A
$ Low-High
$ High-Low
Newest
Oldest
78 products
Emilie Unicorn Paci Lovey
Emilie Unicorn Paci Lovey
Regular price
$10.95
Sale price
$10.95
Sale
Star Pony Sshumplie
Star Pony Sshumplie
Regular price
$22.99
Sale price
$22.99
Sale
Eastern Cotton Mouth 54"
Eastern Cotton Mouth 54"
Regular price
$17.95
Sale price
$17.95
Sale
Ball Python Snake
Ball Python Snake
Regular price
$17.95
Sale price
$17.95
Sale
Marshmallow Giraffe
Marshmallow Giraffe
Regular price
$25.95
Sale price
$25.95
Sale
Louie Corgi
Louie Corgi
Regular price
$18.95
Sale price
$18.95
Sale
Kyrie Red Panda Soft
Kyrie Red Panda Soft
Regular price
$21.95
Sale price
$21.95
Sale
Marshmallow Junior Puppy
Marshmallow Junior Puppy
Regular price
$17.95
Sale price
$17.95
Sale
Sequin Rainbow Twist Snake 54"
Sequin Rainbow Twist Snake 54"
Regular price
$19.95
Sale price
$19.95
Sale
Sweet and Sassy Snake Polka Dot 54
Sweet and Sassy Snake Polka Dot 54
Regular price
$22.95
Sale price
$22.95
Sale
Links Pink Snake
Links Pink Snake
Regular price
$17.95
Sale price
$17.95
Sale
Lottie Leopard Cub Softie
Lottie Leopard Cub Softie
Regular price
Sold out
Sale price
$21.95
Sale
Marshmallow Fawn
Marshmallow Fawn
Regular price
$25.95
Sale price
$25.95
Sale
Lil' Baby Shark
Lil' Baby Shark
Regular price
$10.95
Sale price
$10.95
Sale
Marshmallow Happy Horse
Marshmallow Happy Horse
Regular price
$25.95
Sale price
$25.95
Sale
Flappy Bat Soft
Flappy Bat Soft
Regular price
$14.95
Sale price
$14.95
Sale
Angora Black White Guinea Pig
Angora Black White Guinea Pig
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Sale
Marsh Polar Bear
Marsh Polar Bear
Regular price
$26.95
Sale price
$26.95
Sale
Auggie Tan Puppy Sshlumpie
Auggie Tan Puppy Sshlumpie
Regular price
$22.99
Sale price
$22.99
Sale
Cheekie Corgi Soft
Cheekie Corgi Soft
Regular price
$20.95
Sale price
$20.95
Sale
Capybara Squishable
Capybara Squishable
Regular price
$28.99
Sale price
$28.99
Sale
Blitzen Sloth w/winter hat
Blitzen Sloth w/winter hat
Regular price
$14.95
Sale price
$14.95
Sale
Cal Brown Bear
Cal Brown Bear
Regular price
Sold out
Sale price
$22.95
Sale
Spunky Hedgehog w/winter hat
Spunky Hedgehog w/winter hat
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Sale
Sasquatch w/Bomber Hat
Sasquatch w/Bomber Hat
Regular price
$14.95
Sale price
$14.95
Sale
Putty Glitters Reindeer
Putty Glitters Reindeer
Regular price
$20.95
Sale price
$20.95
Sale
Merrie Mouse w/red hat and candy cane
Merrie Mouse w/red hat and candy cane
Regular price
$11.95
Sale price
$11.95
Sale
Peppy-Mint Snail
Peppy-Mint Snail
Regular price
$11.95
Sale price
$11.95
Sale
Mashmallow Latte Lion
Mashmallow Latte Lion
Regular price
$25.95
Sale price
$25.95
Sale
Marshmallow Junior Monkey
Marshmallow Junior Monkey
Regular price
$17.95
Sale price
$17.95
Sale
Marshmallow Junior Stegosaurus
Marshmallow Junior Stegosaurus
Regular price
$17.95
Sale price
$17.95
Sale
PJ's Chocolate Lab Medium
PJ's Chocolate Lab Medium
Regular price
$23.95
Sale price
$23.95
Sale
PJ's Chocolate Lab Small
PJ's Chocolate Lab Small
Regular price
$15.95
Sale price
$15.95
Sale
Boogie Bearded Dragon Soft
Boogie Bearded Dragon Soft
Regular price
$24.95
Sale price
$24.95
Sale
Earie Fennec Fox Mini Soft
Earie Fennec Fox Mini Soft
Regular price
$14.95
Sale price
$14.95
Sale
Gingerbread Girl II
Gingerbread Girl II
Regular price
$12.95
Sale price
$12.95
Sale
Andie Owl Soft
Andie Owl Soft
Regular price
$21.95
Sale price
$21.95
Sale
Elsie Cow Mini Soft
Elsie Cow Mini Soft
Regular price
$14.95
Sale price
$14.95
Sale
Previous page
Page 2 of 2
Next page
Invalid Password
Enter
choosing a selection results in a full page refresh
